190 characters, but most votes clumped at the top.

Matt regrets making sci-fi and comic characters separate lists.

Matt entered the contest again and promises he didn't cheat.

Characters That Received One Runner-Up Vote

• The Wizard of Oz
• Union of Jack
• Thor
• The Spectre
• The Governor
• Taskmaster
• Stupid Rat Creatures (Bone)
• Storm
• Splinter
• The Spirit
• Smiley Bone (Bone)
• Shredder
• Scarecrow
• Sam Slade
• Rogue Trooper
• Rogue
• Rhino
• Red Skull
• Red Sonja
• Raven (Zoids)
• PJ Maybe
• Oracle
• Nightwing
• Mysterio
• Mr. Fantastic
• Mogo
• Mishone
• Lobo
• Lex Luthor
• Kilowagg
• Kenzie (Mouseguard)
• Judge Dredd (Judge Dredd)
• John Carter
• Jarvis
• J. Jonah Jameson
• Hardigan
• Grimjack
• Green Goblin
• Gaeta Fix
• Gambit
• Frobisher
• Foggy Nelson
• Felicity Smoak
• Eradicator
• Dum Dum Dugan
• Doctor Doom
• David Kane
• Damien Wayne
• The Crow
• Cow (Cow and Boy)
• Conduit
• Cloak and Dagger
• Carnage
• Captain Haddock
• Bullseye
• Bruce Banner
• Bizarro
• Batwoman
• Batgirl
• Asterix
• Archie
• Archer
• Adam Warlock

Ben came up with a better vote tabulation process in a dream. And it worked.

Characters That Received Multiple Runner-Up Votes

• Venom
• Superboy
• Rahm Space Knight
• Rick Grimes
• Obelix
• Nova
• Johnny Alpha
• Iron Fist
• Hawkeye
• Groot
• Galactus
• Fone Bone (Bone)
• Deadshot
• Darkseid
• Bane
• The Riddler
• Ras Al Ghul
• Hobbes (Calvin and Hobbes)
• Green Arrow
• Catwoman
• Ant-Man
• She-Hulk
• Luke Cage
• Jessica Jones
• Deathstroke
• Commissioner Gordon
• Alfred E. Newman
• Professor X
• Blue Beetle
• Captain Marvel
• The Tick
• Stupendous Man
• Scarlet Witch
• Ronin
• Phil Coulson
• Moon Knight
• Mockingbird
• Michaelangelo (the ninja turtle, not the painter)
• Killraven
• Jenson (The Loozards)
• Hank Henshaw
• Edward Hyde (The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen)
• Charlie Brown
• Doctor Octopus
• Peggy Carter
• Linus
• Leonardo (the turtle, not the inventor)
• Jonah Hex
• Imperiex
• Domino
• Beast
• Doctor Hugo Strange
• Silver Surfer
• Brainiac
• Black Panther
• Zenith
• Space Pig Hamidius
• The Shade
• Peppermint Patty
• Old Lace
• Nick Fury
• Miles Morales
• Lois Lane
• Jean Grey
• Doomsday
• Alfred Pennyworth
• Two-Face
• Rocket Raccoon
• Pa Kent
• Squirrel Girl
• Tintin
• Killgrave
• Kid Flash
• Conan the Barbarian
• Captain Cold
• Cable
• Shatterstar